 | Adams State University | Alamosa, CO | Super Region 6 | Jason Ramstetter | Adams State Grizzlies | 1968 |
 | Allen University | Columbia, SC | Super Region 2 | Eric Pack | Website | 2016 |
 | Ashland University | Ashland, OH | Super Region 3 | Marcus Gordon | Ashland Eagles | 1961 |
 | Augustana University (SD) | Sioux Falls, SD | Super Region 5 | Jason Reitmeier | Augustana Vikings | 1962 |
 | Belmont Abbey College | Belmont, NC | Super Region 2 | Randy DeAngelo | Website | 2005 |
 | Bluefield State University | Bluefield, WV | Super Region 3 | Samuel Gardner | Bluefield State Big Blue | 2020 |
 | Bluefield State University | Bluefield, WV | Super Region 3 | Gamon Trigg | Bluefield State Big Blue | 2020 |
 | Cal Poly Humboldt | Arcata, CA | Super Region 6 | Anthony Mancini | Website | 2025 |
 | Chadron State College | Chadron, NE | Super Region 6 | Taygen Smith | Chadron State Eagles | 1970 |
 | Coker University | Hartsville, SC | Super Region 2 | Noah Korenoski | Coker Cobras | 2012 |
 | Colorado Mesa University | Grand Junction, CO | Super Region 6 | Mike Mendoza | Colorado Mesa Mavericks | 2006 |
 | Colorado School of Mines | Golden, CO | Super Region 6 | Austin DeVoe | Colorado Mines Orediggers | 1919 |
 | Colorado State University Pueblo | Pueblo, CO | Super Region 6 | Dax Charles | Colorado Pueblo Thunderwolves | 2008 |
 | Davenport University | Grand Rapids, MI | Super Region 3 | Scott Lucas | Davenport Panthers | 2014 |
 | Davis and Elkins College | Elkins, WV | Super Region 3 | Matthew Danner | Davis & Elkins Senators | 2018 |
 | Drury University | Springfield, MO | Super Region 4 | Bryce Walker | Drury Panthers | 2016 |
 | East Stroudsburg University | East Stroudsburg, PA | Super Region 1 | Anibal Nieves | East Stroudsburg Warriors | 1929 |
 | Emmanuel University | Franklin Springs, GA | Super Region 2 | Bryce Killian | Website | 2014 |
 | Emory & Henry College | Emory, VA | Super Region 3 | Jeramiah Hampton | Emory & Henry Wasps | 2019 |
 | Fairmont State University | Fairmont, WV | Super Region 1 | Gennaro Bonaventura | Website | 2019 |
 | Felician University | Rutherford, NJ | Super Region 1 | Dale Fava | Felician University Golden Falcons | 2024 |
 | Fort Hays State | Hays, KS | Super Region 6 | Erik Wince | Fort Hays State Tigers | 1956 |
 | Frostburg State University | Frostburg, MD | Super Region 1 | Josh Hutchens | Website | 2023 |
 | Gannon University | Erie, PA | Super Region 1 | Tom Boyd | Gannon Golden Knights | 1967 |
 | Glenville State College | Glenville, WV | Super Region 3 | Dylan Cottrell | Website | 2020 |
 | Grand Valley State University | Allendale, MI | Super Region 3 | Richard "RJ" Boudro | Grand Valley State Lakers | 1967 |
 | Kentucky Wesleyan College | Owensboro, KY | Super Region 4 | Jacob Lorentz | Website | 2017 |
 | King University | Bristol, TN | Super Region 2 | Blaze Shade | King Tornado | 2005 |
 | Kutztown University | Kutztown, PA | Super Region 1 | Ziad Haddad | Kutztown Golden Bears | 1940 |
 | Lake Erie College | Painesville, OH | Super Region 3 | John Penfold | Lake Erie Storm | 2009 |
 | Lander University | Greenwood, SC | Super Region 2 | R.C. LaHaye | Website | 2018 |
 | Lincoln Memorial University | Harrogate, TN | Super Region 2 | Vacant | Website | 2021 |
 | Maryville University | St. Louis, MO | Super Region 4 | Charlie Sherertz | Maryville Saints | 2011 |
 | McKendree University | Lebanon, IL | Super Region 4 | James Kisgen | McKendree Bearcats | 2002 |
 | Menlo College | Atherton, CA | Super Region 6 | Zeke Andrade | Website | 2001 |
 | Millersville University | Millersville, PA | Super Region 1 | Jerry Boland | Millersville Marauders | 1946 |
 | Minnesota State University | Mankato, MN | Super Region 5 | Brady Wilson | Minnesota State Mavericks | 1950 |
 | Minnesota State University Moorhead | Moorhead, MN | Super Region 5 | Kris Nelson | Website | 1952 |
 | Minot State University | Minot, ND | Super Region 5 | Gresh Jones | Minot State Beavers | 2010 |
 | New Mexico Highlands University | Las Vegas, NM | Super Region 6 | Chris Freije | New Mexico Highlands Cowboys | 2006 |
 | Newberry College | Newberry, SC | Super Region 2 | Deral Brown | Newberry Wolves | 2004 |
 | Newman University | Wichita, KS | Super Region 4 | Mitch Arnold | Newman Jets | 2004 |
 | Northeastern State University | Tahlequah, OK | Super Region 4 | Terry Pack | Website | 2026 |
 | Northern State University | Aberdeen, SD | Super Region 5 | Josh Nolan | Northern State Wolves | 1964 |
 | Ouachita Baptist University | Arkadelphia, AR | Super Region 4 | Kevin Crutchmer | Ouachita Baptist Tigers | 2010 |
 | Point Park University | Pittsburgh, PA | | Zach Mizer | Website | 2024 |
 | Quincy University | Quincy, IL | Super Region 4 | Jimmy Eggemeyer | Website | 2022 |
 | Salem University | Salem, WV | Super Region 3 | Cole Houser | Salem University Tigers | 2024 |
 | San Francisco State University | San Francisco, CA | Super Region 6 | Jason Welch | San Francisco State Gators | 1939 |
 | Seton Hill University | Greensburg, PA | Super Region 1 | Vince DeAugustine | Seton Hill Griffons | 2006 |
 | Shippensburg University | Shippensburg, PA | Super Region 1 | Seth Bloomquist | Shippensburg Raiders | 1973 |
 | Shorter University | Rome, GA | Super Region 2 | Andrew Colborn | Shorter University Hawks | 2011 |
 | Simon Fraser University | Burnaby, BC | Super Region 6 | Clete Hanson | Simon Fraser Red Leafs | 1976 |
 | Slippery Rock University | Slippery Rock, PA | | Jeff Breese | | 2027 |
 | Southwest Minnesota State University | Marshall, MN | Super Region 5 | Chayse Jackson | Southwest Minnesota State Mustangs | 1967 |
 | St. Cloud State University | Saint Cloud, MN | Super Region 5 | Steve Costanzo | St. Cloud State Huskies | 1949 |
 | Thomas More University | Crestview Hills, KY | Super Region 4 | Jason Russell | Website | 2015 |
 | Tiffin University | Tiffin, OH | Super Region 3 | Antonio Guerra | Tiffin Dragons | 2009 |
 | University of Bridgeport | Bridgeport, CT | Region 1 | Mario Morgan | Website | 2025 |
 | University of Central Missouri | Warrensburg, MO | Super Region 4 | Cody Garcia | Central Missouri Mules | 1963 |
 | University of Central Oklahoma | Edmond, OK | Super Region 4 | Todd Steidley | Central Oklahoma Bronchos | 1972 |
 | University of Findlay | Findlay, OH | Super Region 3 | Shawn Nelson | Findlay Roughnecks | 1938 |
 | University of Indianapolis | Indianapolis, IN | Super Region 4 | Jason Warthan | Indianapolis Greyhounds | 1956 |
 | University of Jamestown | Jamestown, ND | Super Region 5 | Christian Komitas | Website | 1976 |
 | University of Mary | Bismarck, ND | Super Region 5 | Adam Aho | Mary Marauders | 1987 |
 | University of Montevallo | Montevallo, AL | Super Region 2 | Daniel Ownbey | Montevallo Falcons | 2023 |
 | University of Mount Olive | Mount Olive, NC | Super Region 2 | Dan Willis | Website | 2018 |
 | University of Nebraska Kearney | Kearney, NE | Super Region 6 | Dalton Jensen | Nebraska-Kearney Lopers | 1960 |
 | University of North Carolina at Pembroke | Pembroke, NC | Super Region 2 | Othello Johnson | UNC-Pembroke Braves | 1982 |
 | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | Johnstown, PA | Super Region 1 | Tyler Reinhart | Pitt-Johnstown Mountain Cats | 1974 |
 | University of Sioux Falls | Sioux Falls, SD | Super Region 5 | Matt Meuleners | Website | 2023 |
 | University of Wisconsin-Parkside | Kenosha, WI | Super Region 5 | Nick Becker | UW-Parkside Rangers | 1969 |
 | Upper Iowa University | Fayette, IA | Super Region 5 | Heath Grimm | Upper Iowa Peacocks | 1958 |
 | Vanguard University | Costa Mesa, CA | Super Region 6 | Caleb Flores | Website | 2019 |
 | West Liberty University | West Liberty, WV | Super Region 3 | Daniel Irwin | West Liberty Hilltoppers | 1962 |
 | Western Colorado University | Gunnison, CO | Super Region 6 | Charlie Pipher | Western Colorado Mountaineers | 1956 |
 | Wheeling University | Wheeling, WV | Super Region 1 | Shane Brown | Wheeling Cardinals | 2013 |