| Arizona Christian University |
Phoenix, AZ |
Cascade Collegiate |
Arizona Christian Firestorm |
2018 |
| Arkansas Baptist College |
Little Rock, AR |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletics |
Arkansas Baptist Buffalos |
2011 |
| Avila University |
Kansas City, MO |
Kansas Collegiate |
Avila Eagles |
2020 |
| Baker University (Kan.) |
Baldwin City, KS |
Heart of America |
Baker University Wildcats |
2008 |
| Benedictine College |
Atchison, KS |
Heart of America |
Benedictine College Ravens |
2011 |
| Bethany (Kan.) |
Lindsborg, KS |
Kansas Collegiate |
Bethany Swedes |
2011 |
| Bluefield College |
Bluefield, VA |
Appalachian |
Bluefield College Rams |
2017 |
| Brewton-Parker |
Mount Vernon, GA |
Mid-South |
Brewton-Parker Barons |
2012 |
| Briar Cliff (Iowa) |
Sioux, IA |
Great Plains |
Briar Cliff Chargers |
1997 |
| Campbellsville (KY) |
Campbellsville, KY |
Mid-South |
Campbellsville Tigers |
2004 |
| Central Baptist |
Conway, AR |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletics |
Central Baptist Mustangs |
2010 |
| Central Christian College |
McPherson, KS |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletics |
Central Christian Tigers |
2016 |
| Cleary |
Howell, MI |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference |
Cleary Cougars |
2016 |
| Concordia (Neb.) |
Seward, NE |
Great Plains |
Concordia Stingers |
2009 |
| Corban University |
Salem, OR |
Cascade Collegiate |
Corban Warriors |
2018 |
| Cornerstone University |
Grand Rapids, MI |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference |
Cornerstone Golden Eagles |
2021 |
| Cumberland (Tenn.) |
Lebanon, TN |
Mid-South |
Cumberland Phoenix |
1998 |
| Cumberlands (Ky.) |
Wiliamsburg, KY |
Mid-South |
Cumberland Patriots |
1996 |
| Dakota Wesleyan (S.D.) |
Mitchell, SD |
Great Plains |
Dakota Wesleyan Tigers |
1963 |
| Dickinson State (N.D) |
Dickinson, ND |
Heart of America |
Dickinson State Blue Hawks |
1959 |
| Doane University |
Crete, NE |
Great Plains |
Doane Tigers |
2013 |
| Eastern Oregon University |
La Grande, OR |
Cascade Collegiate |
Eastern Oregon Mountaineers |
2016 |
| Embry-Riddle |
Prescott, AZ |
Cascade Collegiate |
Embry-Riddle Eagles |
1988 |
| Evergreen State |
Olympia, WA |
Wolverine-Hoosier |
Evergreen Vikings |
2023 |
| Friends University |
Wichita, KS |
Kansas Collegiate |
Friends Falcons |
2020 |
| Graceland University |
Lamoni, IA |
Heart of America |
Graceland Yellowjackets |
2013 |
| Grand View (Iowa) |
Des Moines, IA |
Heart of America |
Grand View Vikings |
2007 |
| Hannibal-LaGrange (Mo) |
Hannibal, MO |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletics |
Hannibal-LaGrange Trojans |
2007 |
| Hastings (Neb.) |
Hastings, NE |
Great Plains |
Hastings Broncos |
2007 |
| Indiana Tech |
Fort Wayne, IN |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic |
Indiana Tech Warriors |
2011 |
| Iowa Wesleyan University |
Mt. Pleasant, IA |
Heart of America |
Iowa Wesleyan Tigers |
2019 |
| Jarvis Christian University |
Hawkins, TX |
|
Jarvis Christian Bulldogs |
2021 |
| Keiser University |
Ft. Lauderdale, FL |
Appalachian Athletic |
Keiser Seahawks |
2018 |
| Life University |
Marietta, GA |
Appalachian Athletic |
Life Running Eagles |
2012 |
| Lindsey Wilson (Ky.) |
Columbia, KY |
Mid-South |
Lindsey Wilson Blue Raiders |
2008 |
| Lourdes University |
Sylvania, OH |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic |
Lourdes Gray Wolves |
2015 |
| Lyon College |
Batesville, AR |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletics |
Lyon Scots |
2013 |
| Marian University |
Indianapolis, IN |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic |
Marian Knights |
2015 |
| Menlo (Calif.) |
Atherton, CA |
Cascade Collegiate |
Menlo Oaks |
2001 |
| Midland University |
Fremont, NE |
Great Plains |
Midland Warriors |
2010 |
| Midway University |
Midway, KY |
Mid-South |
Midway Eagles |
2017 |
| Missouri Baptist University |
St Louis, MO |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletic |
Missouri Baptist Spartans |
2001 |
| Missouri Valley College |
Marshall, MO |
Heart of America |
Missouri Valley Vikings |
1991 |
| Montana State-Northern |
Harve, MT |
Cascade Collegiate |
Montana State Northern Lights |
1984 |
| Montreat College |
Montreat, NC |
Appalachian Athletic |
Montreat Cavaliers |
2019 |
| Morningside (Iowa) |
Sioux City, IA |
Great Plains |
Morningside Mustangs |
2004 |
| Northwestern (Iowa) |
Orange City, IA |
Great Plains |
Northwestern Raiders |
1974 |
| Oklahoma City |
Oklahoma City, OK |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletic |
Oklahoma City Stars |
2006 |
| Oklahoma Wesleyan |
Bartlesville, OK |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
Oklahoma Wesleyan Eagles |
2016 |
| Ottawa University |
Ottawa, KS |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
Ottawa Braves |
2018 |
| Reinhardt University |
Waleska, GA |
Appalachian Athletic |
Reinhardt Eagles |
2016 |
| Rochester University |
Rochester Hills, MI |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference |
Rochester Warriors |
2018 |
| Siena Heights University |
Hudson, MI |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference |
Siena Heights Saints |
2019 |
| Simpson (Calif.) |
Redding, CA |
Cascade Collegiate |
Simpson Storm |
2012 |
| Southeastern |
Lakeland, FL |
Appalachian Athletic |
Southeastern Fire |
2014 |
| Southern Oregon |
Ashland, OR |
Cascade Collegiate |
Southern University Raiders |
1956 |
| St. Ambrose University |
Davenport, IA |
Heart of America |
St. Ambrose Fighting Bees |
2020 |
| St. Andrews University |
Laurinburg, NC |
Appalachian Athletic |
St. Andrew Knights |
2006 |
| St. Mary (KS) |
Levanworth, KS |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
St. Mary Spires |
2016 |
| St. Thomas University |
Miami Gardens, FL |
Appalachian Athletic |
St. Thomas Tommies |
2019 |
| Texas Wesleyan University |
Fort Worth, TX |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletic |
Texas Wesleyan Rams |
2018 |
| Thomas More College |
Crestview Hills, KY |
Mid-South |
Thomas More Saints |
2015 |
| Truett McConnel University |
Cleveland, GA |
Appalachian Athletic |
Truett McConnel Bears |
2011 |
| Univ. of Providence (Mont.) |
Great Falls, MT |
Cascade Collegiate |
Providence Argonauts |
2003 |
| Univ. of Health Sciences and Pharmacy |
St. Louis, MO |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletic |
Univ. of Health Sciences and Pharmacy Eutectics |
2021 |
| University of Jamestown (N.D.) |
Jamestown, ND |
Great Plains |
Jamestown Jimmies |
1976 |
| University of Rio Grande |
Rio Grandee, OH |
Mid-South |
Rio Grande Red Storm |
2020 |
| Vanguard University |
Costa Mesa, CA |
American Midwest |
Vanguard Gold Pride |
2019 |
| Waldort (Iowa) |
Forest City, IA |
Mid-South |
Waldorf Warriors |
1968 |
| Warner Pacific University |
Portland, OR |
Cascade Collegiate |
Warner Pacific Knights |
2014 |
| Wayland Baptist (Texas) |
Plainview, TX |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletic |
Wayland Baptist Pioneers |
2009 |
| West Virginia Tech (W. Va) |
Montgomery, WV |
Appalachian Athletic |
West Virginia Golden Bear |
2007 |
| William Penn (Iowa) |
Oskaloosa, IA |
Heart of America |
William Penn Statesmen |
1972 |
| William Woods |
Futon, MO |
|
William Woods Owls |
2023 |
| Williams Baptist College |
Walnut Ridge, AR |
American Midwest / Sooner Athletic |
William Baptist Eagles |
2013 |
| York (Neb.) |
York, NE |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
York Cardinals |
2006 |
